Solar without Storage in not Sustainable

Nitya Nanda, a Senior Researcher at TERI, emphasized that India needs to build a storage system for electricity from its fast-expanding solar network to balance cost-effective energy mix. Nanda stated that there is a mismatch between peak demand and electricity generation period for solar.

The solar electricity must be stored for use during peak period, which is late at night (10:00 PM to past midnight), while the energy can be harnessed in afternoon (12:00 PM to 4:00 PM),” Nanda told a workshop on South Asia’s Challenges and Opportunities in Sustainable Energy Transitions held by Singapore’s Institute of South Asian Studies and Energy Studies Institute yesterday.

While solar is seen as the cheapest form of electricity, as the latest bid shows that it could be available at less than Rs 2.5 per unit and hence one can imagine a situation where solar power price go down to Rs 1-1.5 per unit, it is in a conundrum on supply and demand scenario, Nanda said

However, Nanda expressed concern over the high cost of the storage system, mostly to be a battery-based setup. This would raise the solar electricity cost to the consumer to Rs 10 per 2.5 kV, from just nominal right now, he said. In such a case, coal-fired power plants will be more competitive with the green-energy, he pointed out.

India’s coal-plant electricity would compete with solar during the off-peak period in the day, say, at Re 1.

But as the night sets in, it would raise prices to as high as Rs 10, as solar without storage would no longer be in competition, or with storage system be offered at Rs 10 at least.

Solar operate at a nominal cost as no fuel cost is involved and maintenance cost is the only operational cost.

Comparatively, coal-fired plant s cost is Rs 2 and above and it faces rising coal prices as well as environmental issues.

India’s coal-fired plants also lack the flexibility of shutting during the off-peak period.

They are old and designed to operate 24/7, which compels the operators to run at full capacity and compete on prices in the marketplace.

Building a coal-fired plant with flexibility to shut and restart will take a long time, and it is an option not in line with the Indian governments green energy and enhancing environment programmes.

Comparatively, India’s slow-paced industrialisation would also not be able to support the 100-GW solar electricity output, he pointed out.

Higher industrial growth could generate higher demand during daytime

Producing electricity without demand and or storage is wastage.

Nanda observed that India has made good progress on the ambitious solar development, 100-gigawatt by 2022, but has raised concern about backup of the green electricity.

India has already installed 16 GW of solar plants and 40 GW of other green energy networks including Wind, of the total 175-GW target by 2022


A group of tech enthusiasts who are tracking latest developments in CleanTech with special focus on Energy Storage and Electric Mobility

About Energy Log Staff

A group of tech enthusiasts who are tracking latest developments in CleanTech with special focus on Energy Storage and Electric Mobility

View all posts by Energy Log Staff →

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *